Advertising: contextual vs. behavioral and why it matters
July 1, 2019
This might come as a surprise to some of you, but I haven't always worked with UX. In fact, my last few full time positions were at advertising agencies where I worked on advertising campaigns and not digital products and tools. This was a very different time, of course, as it was pre-content marketing, pre-influencers, and pre-"thought leaders" (shrugs). I spent nearly five years with advertising agencies like BBDO and Bates Y&R leading their digital efforts in online marketing land.
At the time (2005ish) Forsman & Bodenfors had just released their epic online campaign "Dream kitchens" for IKEA - a revolutionary campaign and everyone in the advertising industry wanted to catch-up. Back then, I regularly saw a new campaigns that made my jaw drop they were so inspiring. Even outside of digital, there were campaigns made that made the news even outside of our industry.
Today, the story is very different. Advertising campaigns don't garner the attention they used to and the quality has suffered. They are missing components that drove those mind-blowing advertising experiences. They simply lack that connection to their audience only achieved through creative, relevant storytelling.
Stories
The Sony Bravia advert with the bouncing balls and Honda - The Cog are adverts that still stand strong today. The Sony Bravia is nearly 15 years old and Honda The Cog is even older. These commercials are masterpieces. The craftsmanship in them is something I feel we don't see anymore. These commercials are not based around CGI and they're certainly not tailored to meet your specific interest. You know what they are? They are good stories.
See - even Tyron Lannister knows good marketing
The more companies know about their customers, the harder it seems for them to produce stories that are so universal they speak to everyone. They get stuck trying to find the perfect target audience for each message, but because their data points are so specific, the messaging gets lost and they waste an enormous amount of money.
Even one of the first successful viral video campaigns was based around a story everyone could relate to, a group of friends - just how TV shows like Seinfield and Friends are successful because they address topics that everyone can relate to.
Swap the landlines for iPhones and the ad would still work today.
Where's the creativity?
The annual tête-a-tête for the advertising industry is of course the Cannes Lions festival in France. I used to be super keen on seeing who would get nominated (I was even nominated myself for a campaign I had worked on in 2003!), but I just don't see the creativity anymore. One of this years winners - a gold lion - is Droga5's campaign for Apple. It's surely not a bad campaign in any way, but it's likely it'll just be completely forgotten in a year. Surely, it won't be referenced in blog posts more than 15 years from now!
The Apple campaign shows a team of people working hard to pitch an idea to their boss. So while there is a relatable story, there's zero connection to the greater audience.
What's wrong with advertising?
As companies collect more and more data about you and me, shouldn't their advertising feel even more spot-on for me? After all, they should know me, but in most cases now, I feel like I have no idea who they're talking to. Turns out, it's because they want to show me behavioral ads (aka The New Kid on the Block) and not contextual ads (like we've done for the past 100 years). Companies like Google and Facebook are compiling millions of data points on you to make the perfect profile, but still have no idea how to actually match these data points with advertising that works. Worse yet, they make a ton of money from selling these data points to advertisers (with the promise of being able to tailor ads that will fit me perfectly) so they have no interest in respecting your privacy.
They (Google & Facebook etc) argue that strong privacy laws would hurt the digital ad market, create high costs for businesses and curb innovation.
These are all weak arguments. There is no reason to fear that sites cannot still make money with advertising. That’s because there are already two kinds of highly profitable online ads: contextual ads, based on the content being shown on screen, and behavioral ads, based on personal data collected about the person viewing the ad. Behavioral ads work by tracking your online behavior and compiling a profile about you using your internet activities (and even your offline activities in some cases) to send you targeted ads.
Contextual advertising doesn’t need to know anything about you: Search for “car” and you get a car ad. Over the past decade, contextual ads have been displaced by behavioral ads, aided by the rise of real-time bidding technology that auctions off each ad on a site based on user profiling. These behavioral ads are the ones that leave a bad taste in your mouth. They follow you around from website to mobile app based on your private information and, intentionally or not, enable online discrimination, manipulation and the creation of filter bubbles.
Strong privacy laws will force the digital advertising industry to return to its roots in contextual advertising. That’s a good thing, since contextual advertising does not affect privacy in the same way.
What if we all just sold non-creepy ads?
What you can do
The upside to all of this is that behavioral ads only work when they have the correct data points. If you use services that choose to respect your privacy, the big tech will eventually have to rethink their stand on collecting data. But if you're the CMO or CEO of a company running ads, I'm sure you're thinking that moving to contextual advertising only will reduce your profits, at the end of the day, there's share holders to satisfy.
This shift back to contextual advertising need not reduce profitability. A recent poll by Digiday of publishing executives found that 45 percent of them saw no significant benefit from behavioral ads, and 23 percent said they actually caused a decline in revenue.
So if you're running a business, or if you're working for one, think about what you're building.
But whether you like it or not, what you build and what you create define who you are. It feels a bit crazy that anyone should have to say this. But if you’ve built a chaos factory, you can’t dodge responsibility for the chaos. Taking responsibility means having the courage to think things through. And there are few areas where this is more important than privacy. If we accept as normal and unavoidable that everything in our lives can be aggregated, sold, or even leaked in the event of a hack, then we lose so much more than data. We lose the freedom to be human.Tim Cook’s Stanford Commencement Address
History clearly shows us that you can do great advertising without being intrusive (look at the technology used in the Budweiser commercial and think about what "data points" you think they had). Great stories are timeless and attract everyone. It's time the industry recognizes this.
You need to confirm your email to confirm your subscription.
-
March, 2024
-
February, 2024
-
January, 2024
-
December, 2023
-
November, 2023
-
October, 2023
-
September, 2023
-
August, 2023
-
July, 2023
-
June, 2023
-
May, 2023
-
April, 2023
-
March, 2023
-
January, 2023
-
December, 2022
-
November, 2022
-
September, 2022
-
August, 2022
-
July, 2022
-
June, 2022
-
May, 2022
-
April, 2022
-
January, 2022
-
December, 2021
-
November, 2021
-
October, 2021
-
September, 2021
-
August, 2021
-
July, 2021
-
June, 2021
-
May, 2021
-
April, 2021
-
March, 2021
-
January, 2021
-
November, 2020
-
October, 2020
-
September, 2020
-
August, 2020
-
June, 2020
-
May, 2020
-
April, 2020
-
March, 2020
- Regarding Zoom
- Why wireframes are becoming obsolete
- Get static
- Emotions and work - know yourself
- All books are now free
- Wireframes are too concrete
- Stuck at home
- What Great Managers Do
- From Error to Understanding: The Importance of Brand Voice When Things Go Wrong
- Answering your question - How I design
- The Sliding Scale of Giving a Fuck
- Hard startups
-
February, 2020
-
January, 2020
- Debbie Millman - Time Well Spent
- The last tracker was just removed from Basecamp.com
- Fathom Analytics
- Redesign to learn
- How putting a price on speed helped one retailer increase mobile revenue in just 2 months
- Accessibility drives aesthetics
- Smart people use simple words to make others feel smart.
- The great paradox of our time: everything is both better and worse than ever before
-
December, 2019
-
November, 2019
-
October, 2019
-
September, 2019
-
August, 2019
- How we work with microcopy
- Measuring UX with HEART
- Mobile E-Commerce UX: Deemphasize ‘Install App’ Ads or Avoid Them Entirely
- Analytics are reshaping fashion’s old-school instincts
- What to Do When You Feel Uninspired at Work
- Stay in your lane and outlast your competition
- A Mindful Approach to Technology
- “I Just Knew I Was Going to Surpass These Guys I Was Working For”
- People Are Starting to Realize How Voice Assistants Actually Work
- Fast Software, the Best Software
- Data-Driven Design Is Killing Our Instincts
- Freelance and Business And Stuff
- UX can’t be defined by one set of "rules"
-
July, 2019
- 5 Years - 300+ Posts!
- Superhuman and email privacy
- Why Consultants Quit Their Jobs to Go Independent
- Give them candy: small details make all the difference
- Your inbox is spying on you
- On Modus: It’s Time for a Code of Ethics for Designers
- Frank Chimero on causing ’good trouble’ and re-imagining the status quo to combat achievement culture
- Advertising: contextual vs. behavioral and why it matters
-
June, 2019
- Citrix improves UX and cuts costs by 65%
- Delight Comes Last
- Tim Cook’s Stanford Commencement Address
- You care more about your privacy than you think
- The Cost of Lies
- Let’s assemble like the Avengers and... do work
- Big Mood Machine
- Simplicity is a war
- How Notion Is Going After Atlassian and Why It Just Might Win
- Hiring a Management Consultancy for Digital Is a Mistake
- Just write: why Product Designers should write, and how to get started
- Dos and dont’s on designing for accessibility
- I’ve redesigned my website and it looks exactly the same
-
May, 2019
-
April, 2019
- Scapegoating User Experience Design
- Clip sharing with Overcast
- Why don’t we just use Material Design?
- Accenture sued $32m+ over website redesign for Hertz
- Venture capital money kills more businesses than it helps
- Creating a UX Strategy
- The elegance of nothing
- Amazon Workers Are Listening to What You Tell Alexa
- Working as a UX-lead
- Gumroadday: Get my books at -17% discount
-
March, 2019
- Working as a UX designer
- Meet Q: The First Genderless Voice
- It Doesn’t Have to Be Crazy at Work
- How Notion pulled itself back from the brink of failure
- What’s the meaning of work?
- Wireframes are becoming less relevant — and that’s a good thing
- Neurodiversity and the Digital Divide: how our neurological differences shape the way we experience the web
- Accessibility, a powerful design tool
-
February, 2019
-
January, 2019
-
December, 2018
-
November, 2018
-
October, 2018
-
September, 2018
-
August, 2018
- Living among baby robots
- Yuval Noah Harari on what the year 2050 has in store for humankind
- Voice Input’s Effect on Social Norms
- How I kicked my email compulsion
- Facebook's struggle to moderate itself
- The Secret to Ant Efficiency Is Idleness
- Google Employees Are Organizing To Protest the Company’s Secret Search Engine
- Why Small Teams Win
- Back to Work!
- The Bullshit Web
- Nikhil Sonnad on the banal evil of Facebook
-
July, 2018
- Five questions UX employers should be asking
- Just keep at it
- Yes, Alan, There Is An ROI For UX Design
- High Fives, AI, and Connecting the Dots: MailChimp’s VP of Design on What Business can Learn from Design
- Rands Information Practises
- The Race to a Trillion
- What Elon Musk Should Learn From the Thailand Cave Rescue
- Cheap Shower Curtains
- Tech Sector Values are Broken?
-
June, 2018
- Confirmation Bias in Design
- Rise of the machines: has technology evolved beyond our control?
- Good product writing is conversational
- Retail is Not Dying, But it Has to Evolve
- The Netflix Binge Factory
- We are all trapped in the “Feed”
- Stop “feeding” your users
- Turn off your push notifications. All of them.
- From the Drawing Board to the Board Room
- Think inclusively at every step
- No classes, no professors: the alternative to business school
- Designer Ethics & The Moral Implications of our Apps
- Conversion optimization with A/B tests
-
May, 2018
- AI Ethics - A New Skill for UX-Designers
- Netlify now shows your deploy status on its favicon
- Let them eat cake
- Netflix Culture
- Skype
- How do you learn UX?
- The New Google Assistant
- What Happened to Apple’s Whimsy?
- Who would you trust more with your data, Apple or the government?
- Unfoundered
- Microcontent: A Few Small Words Have a Mega Impact on Business
- Twitter logged all user’s passwords in plain text
- Requests for Personal Data From Apple, Google, and Facebook Compared
- What’s in a pattern name
- GDPR is ruining my life
-
April, 2018
- A Modest Guide to Productivity
- Google Debuts a Standalone To-Do App, Google Tasks
- Apple Should Make an Instagram Clone
- Vanity Metrics
- Tech is not Neutral
- Facebook to exclude North American users from some privacy enhancements
- Netflix has to "produce great content, market it well, serve it up beautifully."
- Sen. Blumenthal: “Your business model is to maximize profit over privacy.”
- Productivity
- My #1 Piece of Advice to Freelancers: Lean Into The Moment
- Design Systems: Better UX through Defined Standards
- Tim Cook - We care about the user experience
- Europe’s tough new data-protection law
- The Real Technology Problem
- Why Small Teams Win
- Whose risk?
- Phone Bored
- Karim Rashid
- Creative Class is open
- Dieter Rams
- Being cash-free puts us at risk of attack: Swedes turn against cashlessness
- What’s a ‘User Experience’ Anyways?
-
March, 2018
- Fake News is spam
- Bleeding Out
- How Tech Giants Design For Transgender Users–Or Don’t
- Don't use the F word (freelancer)
- Dropbox
- Conversational Design
- Everyone Is Going Through Something
- It Doesn’t Have to Be Crazy at Work
- Flight Crews Don’t Decide Where To Fly
- New Tools Don’t Always Equal Productivity
- The seat at the table
- Why Can Everyone Spot Fake News But YouTube, Facebook And Google?
- Cuba
- Bye bye Facebook
- Why I hate your fake redesign
- Givenchy
- Diversity in the design industry
- Your competitors don’t matter
- Apple’s "Sound on the Go" Strategy
- The Most Important Design Skill For An AI-Dominated World
- Love letters to trees
- Amazon has a fix for Alexa’s creepy laughs
- You have to make sure that you’re focused on the thing that matters.
- Voice Input is the Next Big Thing - Or is It?
-
February, 2018
- Specialize
- Pricing Philisophy
- AMP for email is a terrible idea
- Is this Finnish school the perfect design?
- The #1 reason Facebook won’t ever change
- A Year of Learning and Leading UX at Google
- C.A.R.E - A simple framework for user onboarding
- Inside Facebook´s Hellish Two Years
- A better user experience...or?
- Personas
- Reflections on working on an iPad
- Everything Easy is Hard Again
- How to succeed at freelancing
- The iPhone X is Apple’s underrated masterpiece
- Make me think
-
January, 2018
-
December, 2017
-
November, 2017
-
October, 2017
-
September, 2017
-
August, 2017
-
July, 2017
-
June, 2017
- The Why before the Why
- No Share Buttons on Mobile Sites
- Groundwork for Creating Great User Experiences
- ARKit
- 4 Reasons Why Your Body Text Should be Bigger
- Now that Apple is talking about AR and VR, should we be too?
- Think like an artist to create better designs
- Investing in businesses and products
- 10 Reasons Why All Designers Should Start Writing More
- Become a better UX-designer with these three words
- Vox Media Accessibility Guidelines
- Writing for UX: some practical tips
-
May, 2017
-
April, 2017
-
March, 2017
-
February, 2017
-
January, 2017
-
December, 2016
-
November, 2016
-
October, 2016
-
September, 2016
-
August, 2016
-
July, 2016
-
June, 2016
-
May, 2016
-
April, 2016
-
March, 2016
-
February, 2016
-
January, 2016
-
December, 2015
-
November, 2015
-
October, 2015
-
September, 2015
-
August, 2015
-
July, 2015
-
June, 2015
-
May, 2015
-
April, 2015
-
November, 2014
-
April, 2013