What is worth waiting for?

February 25, 2019

What about speed? No, not the Keanu Reeves movie, but the speed of your product. How much thought have you given it? When building a product, speed is the one aspect that I think is often overlooked, yet it’s one of the features we have a lot of influence over.

Take a minute and think about it… Speed can keep us from making a purchase, navigating through a website, or can even seriously harm our view of a brand. We barely notice when a company does it right, but they enjoy huge sales and ensured brand loyalty. It really is the secret feature that everyone knows about.

The list of things you can do to improve your product’s speed is long (and to be honest, often technical). Reducing server requests, minimizing code, and optimizing images are a good place to start. We think, “of course we can do that,” but all of the fancy aesthetic design (custom fonts, etc) choices, new functionality, and increased content cancel out any progress we thought we made. The truth is our users tend to care more about speed than bells and whistles. They want the information now. Did I mention that search engine rankings now consider speed too? How about that?

Bells and whistles can occasionally serve a purpose, but the load time due to analytics and tracking scripts is becoming insane. When the GDPR launched in Europe, USA Today decided to launch a European version without tracking and ads - bringing the page size from 5.2mb to just 500kb - a decrease of nearly 90%!

Nick Heer disassembled a CNN article only to find it contained 11 web fonts (414kb), 4 stylesheets (315kb), 20 frames, 29 XML HTTP requests (500kb) and approximately one hundred (100!) scripts totalling several megabytes.

The vast majority of these resources are not directly related to the information on the page, and I’m including advertising. Many of the scripts that were loaded are purely for surveillance purposes: self-hosted analytics, of which there are several examples; various third-party analytics firms like Salesforce, Chartbeat, and Optimizely; and social network sharing widgets. They churn through CPU cycles and cause my six-year-old computer to cry out in pain and fury. I’m not asking much of it; I have opened a text-based document on the web.
Nick Heer - The Bullshit Web

Speed is a two-way street

While there’s lots you can do to minimize the page load in your end, speed is a two-way street and even with the most efficient product, there’s one thing you can’t control - the user’s connection. We can make our mobile apps load fast, optimize images, and reduce features that aren’t used on mobile, but it’ll only get us so far. If the user is on a slow carrier connection, there’s nothing we can do to improve that situation.

This is a situation that I’ve found myself working around lately in my work. The product I’m working on has many users in Asia with slower connection speeds. Often they also need to go through a VPN as well which slows them even further. So does that mean there’s nothing we can do to better serve these users?

Of course not!

Jacob Nielsen wrote a great article on this topic that we’ve used as a guiding star in our work. The gist of it is this: There are 3 main time limits (which are determined by human perceptual abilities) to keep in mind when optimizing web and application performance.

You can adjust the timings to what fits your situation, but basically we will think of scenarios from these three time limits:

The basic advice regarding response times has been about the same for thirty years [Miller 1968; Card et al. 1991]:

  • 0.1 second is about the limit for having the user feel that the system is reacting instantaneously, meaning that no special feedback is necessary except to display the result.
  • 1.0 second is about the limit for the user's flow of thought to stay uninterrupted, even though the user will notice the delay. Normally, no special feedback is necessary during delays of more than 0.1 but less than 1.0 second, but the user does lose the feeling of operating directly on the data.
  • 10 seconds is about the limit for keeping the user's attention focused on the dialogue. For longer delays, users will want to perform other tasks while waiting for the computer to finish, so they should be given feedback indicating when the computer expects to be done. Feedback during the delay is especially important if the response time is likely to be highly variable, since users will then not know what to expect.

For anything that’ll take 10 seconds or longer and we’ll show a percentage indicator so the user gets an idea of the anticipated waiting time. Why? Because users don’t actually hate waiting, they hate not knowing how long they’ll have to wait. This is something that call-in customer service center’s have known for years. Call a customer support line and you’ll likely be greeted with the anticipated waiting time. Being told the wait time is 6 minutes may seem like a long time, but waiting for 6 minutes without being told will feel like a whole lot longer.

Not only does being given the the anticipated wait time give you a reference - it gives you something that’s even more valuable to users - the data needed for making a decision! 6 minutes? Ok I’ll hold. 34 minutes? No I’ll call back later. Without knowing the anticipated waiting time we don’t have the knowledge to make that decision. Wouldn’t you want this information for a lot more interactions in your life? Dinner at your mother-in-laws will be four hours. It sounds like you have a decision to make.

Finally, as you’re aware from waiting on the phone - the time remaining decreases. 6 minutes, now it’s 4 minutes and boom - you’re in. The same input is extremely useful dealing with technical data intensive digital tools. Has it crashed? Is it still processing? A visual indicator is there to show the user that the tool is still working - and even to give you something to rest your eyes on! This is why you’re hearing music while waiting on the phone. The music might be pretty terrible, but in most cases, it at least beats silence (and if not, at least give them credit for trying).

No man is an island

Just like no man is an island, no problem has only one solution. It’s therefore important to remember to tackle things like page speed from multiple angles as there’s only so much you can do on each front - but combined you can achieve far greater results. It is important to look creatively at the problem, collaboratively, and present the solution in a way that considers the user’s needs first. While I have some good ideas on how to improve this experience, my opinion is not the end all. It takes many minds to look at a problem as complex as making our speed strangled digital world faster - or at least more tolerable. So, what is your answer? What are the best solutions increasing our speed? How can we make ourselves more comfortable during the inevitable waits? I’m curious to hear what you have to say!

It’s honest, authentic, and accessible.

I love sharing my experiences working in design and what’ve I’ve learned along the way. Join a community of thousands of designers, developers, and product professionals by signing up to my newsletter!

Not quite ready to sign up? I totally understand! Why not start by reading some of my past issues?

Great! Just “one more thing”...

You need to confirm your email to confirm your subscription.

  1. March, 2024

  2. February, 2024

  3. January, 2024

  4. December, 2023

  5. November, 2023

  6. October, 2023

  7. September, 2023

  8. August, 2023

  9. July, 2023

  10. June, 2023

  11. May, 2023

  12. April, 2023

  13. March, 2023

  14. January, 2023

  15. December, 2022

  16. November, 2022

  17. September, 2022

  18. August, 2022

  19. July, 2022

  20. June, 2022

  21. May, 2022

  22. April, 2022

  23. January, 2022

  24. December, 2021

  25. November, 2021

  26. October, 2021

  27. September, 2021

  28. August, 2021

  29. July, 2021

  30. June, 2021

  31. May, 2021

  32. April, 2021

  33. March, 2021

  34. January, 2021

  35. November, 2020

  36. October, 2020

  37. September, 2020

  38. August, 2020

  39. June, 2020

  40. May, 2020

  41. April, 2020

  42. March, 2020

  43. February, 2020

  44. January, 2020

  45. December, 2019

  46. November, 2019

  47. October, 2019

  48. September, 2019

  49. August, 2019

  50. July, 2019

  51. June, 2019

  52. May, 2019

  53. April, 2019

  54. March, 2019

  55. February, 2019

  56. January, 2019

  57. December, 2018

  58. November, 2018

  59. October, 2018

  60. September, 2018

  61. August, 2018

  62. July, 2018

  63. June, 2018

  64. May, 2018

  65. April, 2018

  66. March, 2018

  67. February, 2018

  68. January, 2018

  69. December, 2017

  70. November, 2017

  71. October, 2017

  72. September, 2017

  73. August, 2017

  74. July, 2017

  75. June, 2017

  76. May, 2017

  77. April, 2017

  78. March, 2017

  79. February, 2017

  80. January, 2017

  81. December, 2016

  82. November, 2016

  83. October, 2016

  84. September, 2016

  85. August, 2016

  86. July, 2016

  87. June, 2016

  88. May, 2016

  89. April, 2016

  90. March, 2016

  91. February, 2016

  92. January, 2016

  93. December, 2015

  94. November, 2015

  95. October, 2015

  96. September, 2015

  97. August, 2015

  98. July, 2015

  99. June, 2015

  100. May, 2015

  101. April, 2015

  102. November, 2014

  103. April, 2013